HE SAID:
By Wayne J. Keeley
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
A.C.T.’s production of Beautiful: The Carole King Musical is a visually stunning, incredibly orchestrated and staged (not to mention the acting and singing) story about the history of one of our most iconic singers.
The musical details via nostalgic music her relatively modest beginnings of Carole Klein, a child musical prodigy, to Carole King, one of the most influential modern-day songwriters. I was amazed at how much talent can be gathered and choregraphed in a relatively limited amount of space.
Julia Bain was fantastic as Carole King, proving her singing ability and acting chops. The same can be said for Jake Goz who plays Carole’s husband and co-songwriter Gerry Goffin. Offering comic relief in addition to their own musical talent are Mary Grace Humphries as Cynthia Weil and Barrett Riggins as Barry Mann. Their chemistry is
palpable. There is not enough space to do justice to the rest of the cast which is excellent and essential in bringing this fabulous musical to life. At the very least, they should be individually mentioned: Lisa Sabin, Joseph Torello, Berlin Lee Charles, Diedre Dunkin, Cameron Edris, Audrey Taylor Floyd, Chance Ingalls, Se’Lah Jackson, Elijah James, Jamonte, Gia Marino Christopher Scurlock, Jillian A. Smith, Soraiah Williams, Annie-Sophie Hill, and last but not least, Gabe Nelson (WHEW!).
Carole King’s 1971 Tapestry (which I will now date myself by saying I kept the vinyl In the front of my record rack) swept four major Grammy Awards and has withstood the test of time as a master class in songwriting. Carole was not only a songwriter but an ardent human rights activist and philanthropist.
The play should not be viewed as “just” a jukebox musical, but is deeper than that, showing a nostalgic piece of history and the changing times that America went through in the 60s and 70s. More importantly, one of its main themes is the thing we think we don’t have inside of us (like being a lyricist), can be found and was there all along—we just needed to reach into ourselves.
Beautiful is a beautiful musical and a must-see.
For complete transparency, no AI was used in this review. Additionally, I produced a documentary with Carole King in 1993 about deforestation titled Evolution’s End? The Clear Cut Facts. Carole appeared in and narrated the documentary.
SHE SAID:
By Stephanie C. Lyons-Keeley
A.C.T. of CT Gives Us the Heartbeat in Carole King’s Tapestry
When we look at cultural icons, it’s easy to treat them like they’re carved in marble—untouchable, perfectly formed legends who never lived paycheck to paycheck or had to beat down doors to get someone to listen. What makes Beautiful: The Carole King Musical such an immense joy is that it knocks the proverbial pedestal away. Douglas McGrath’s book hands us a story in which any of us can see ourselves: having talent and a dream, putting in the sweat equity, and having absolutely no idea where the path will lead.
Seeing this stunner of a musical at A.C.T. of Connecticut makes that human scale hit even closer to home. They pride themselves on bringing Broadway to Ridgefield, but with a crucial advantage: intimacy. There truly isn’t a bad seat in the house, which means you aren’t squinting from a distant mezzanine; you’re practically in the studio with them, catching every shared glance, nervous laugh, and knowing smile.
As a writer for stage, screen, and TV, creative hustle resonates deep in my bones. Like Carole and her husband, Gerry, I’ve spent years collaborating with my own partner in love, life, and storytelling. We’re a matched set—perhaps it’s quantum entanglement—grinding away, bouncing ideas across the room, and, like Carole and Gerry, holding onto the hope that our “someday” is within reach. Watching their dynamic unfold felt so deeply, authentically familiar (minus personal unravelings, of course—we stick to the creative friction and the near-nightly breaks we take at our favorite restaurants).
None of that emotional resonance works without a cast that can carry the vocal and dramatic weight, and this company rises to the occasion at every single turn. As Carole King, Julia Bain is phenomenal. Rather than simply doing a vocal impression, she inhabits King’s spirit, allowing the journey from timid Brooklyn teenager and young
mother to unfold into a confident solo artist. When she finally sits at the piano for Tapestry, the transformation feels thoroughly earned. Opposite her, Jake Goz finds the messy, charismatic, and ultimately heartbreaking humanity in Gerry Goffin, never reducing him to just a cheating husband or a cardboard villain.
Playing the other half of this quartet of best friends and chart rivals, Mary Grace Humphries (Cynthia Weil) and Barrett Riggins (Barry Mann) are a comedic and musical delight. Their snappy banter crackles with real affection, balancing healthy competitive fire with genuine loyalty and friendship. Rounding out the characters, Joseph Torello is fantastic as music publisher and producer, Don Kirshner; and Lisa Sabin as Genie Klein was a blast as Carole’s sometimes supportive and very melodramatic mother. And for anyone who loves the era’s pop history, the parade of Aldon Music talent is a wave of pure nostalgia. Beyond the slick, silky harmonies of The Drifters and The Shirelles, the ensemble nails showstopping turns as Neil Sedaka, a high-octane Little Eva doing The Locomotion, and The Righteous Brothers delivering that soulful, floor-shaking sound.
Director and choreographer Parker Esse keeps the staging brisk and buoyant, giving the tender moments room to breathe without ever losing the show’s purely infectious momentum. Alex Gutierrez’s music direction drives the band with punch and polish, while the lighting and scenic work keep the transitions seamless.
Beautiful reminds us that life rarely follows the exact roadmap we draw for it (or these days, the one we put in our GPS), and that the detour is often where the good stuff lies. I walked out into the crisp night feeling recharged, humming the soundtrack of a generation, and holding my hubby’s hand just a little tighter.
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical runs through November 22 at A.C.T. of Connecticut, 36 Old Quarry Road, Ridgefield.

